Parishioner cites biblical teaching on becoming one flesh as evidence that Holy Orders must also be shared.
A Catholic parishioner has challenged the Church's understanding of Holy Orders after discovering that her husband's ordination to the permanent diaconate did not automatically confer ecclesiastical authority upon her.
Margaret, 63, has regarded herself as an integral part of the ordained ministry since her husband, Michael, became a deacon twelve years ago.
“Obviously, Michael was the one who knelt before the bishop,” she explained. “But Scripture tells us that husband and wife become one flesh. If we're one flesh, surely we're one ordination.”
Margaret cited Genesis 2:24 in support of her position, arguing that the Church could hardly insist upon the unity of marriage while refusing to recognise its implications for the diaconate.
“You can't have it both ways.”
She recalled that, following the ordination, a bishop had jokingly informed the assembled wives that their husbands now belonged to him.
“He's my man now,” Margaret remembered him saying.
The joke has subsequently been repeated at almost every gathering of permanent deacons, generally by somebody convinced that the others are hearing it for the first time.
Michael confirmed that he had laughed politely on each occasion.
His wife, however, had identified a more serious theological difficulty.
“If Michael is the bishop's man, and Michael and I are one flesh, then surely I'm the bishop's woman.”
This conclusion has informed Margaret's increasingly expansive understanding of her position within the parish.
While Michael quietly assists at Mass, proclaims the Gospel and visits the sick, Margaret has developed a particular interest in supervising the religious observance of others.
She maintains a detailed knowledge of who attends Mass, who arrives late and which parishioners appear insufficiently conscious of their obligations.
“It's not that I'm judging anybody,” she explained. “I simply think somebody ought to know.”
The parish priest gently clarified that Matrimony and Holy Orders are distinct sacraments, and that the biblical description of husband and wife becoming one flesh does not mean both spouses are ordained.
Margaret expressed disappointment at what she considered an unnecessarily restrictive interpretation of Scripture.
“Father's very traditional about these things.”
Michael was subsequently asked whether he shared his wife's understanding of their joint ministry.
“Not entirely,” he admitted. “I was ordained. Margaret got a very good seat.”
His wife intervened.
“One flesh, Michael.”
The Northern Thurible is an independent Catholic satirical newspaper. The deacon, his wife, parish and conversations are invented. Any resemblance to actual arrangements within the permanent diaconate is unintended, although the longevity of certain clerical jokes cannot be independently disputed.

Leave a Reply