Officials suggest St John Fisher might also have benefited from a more pragmatic approach to relations with the Crown.
Vatican diplomats have concluded that the martyrdoms of St Thomas More and St John Fisher might have been avoided had the Catholic Church adopted a more constructive approach towards Henry VIII.
A retrospective review found that the two saints had demonstrated an unnecessarily rigid attachment to papal authority at a time when the English government was seeking greater involvement in ecclesiastical affairs.
“Nobody is suggesting that His Majesty should control the Church,” explained a diplomatic official. “We merely believe the Crown should have a meaningful role in determining who governs it.”
The official acknowledged that Henry VIII had declared himself Supreme Head of the Church in England, but cautioned against allowing differences over terminology to obstruct dialogue.
“These matters require patience, mutual understanding and a willingness to recognise the legitimate aspirations of the English authorities.”
The review also considered the position of Catholics who had endured imprisonment and execution rather than renounce their allegiance to Rome.
Officials expressed admiration for their courage, while observing that continued resistance could complicate efforts to improve relations with the Crown.
“It is important that the faithful understand the distinction between abandoning one's principles and making the necessary concessions to preserve them.”
Asked whether such an arrangement might compromise the Church's independence, the official offered reassurance.
“The Holy Father would, of course, retain the final say.”
He added that the proposal was entirely hypothetical and should not be confused with the Holy See's existing agreement with the People's Republic of China concerning the appointment of bishops.
“That agreement,” he explained, “is a completely different matter.”
The Northern Thurible is an independent Catholic satirical newspaper. The diplomatic review, officials, dialogue and proposals described are invented for comic purposes. The martyrdoms of St Thomas More and St John Fisher and the existence of the Holy See–China agreement are historical facts. The article draws a satirical comparison between different forms of state involvement in ecclesiastical affairs; it does not suggest that the two arrangements are historically or legally identical.

Leave a Reply