Seventh-century gathering criticised for concluding discussions without establishing a further listening phase.
A group of contemporary Catholic synodal advisers has expressed serious concern following the discovery that the Synod of Whitby, convened in 664, reached a definitive decision on the calculation of Easter.
The gathering, held at the monastery governed by St Hilda, brought together representatives of differing ecclesiastical traditions to resolve a dispute which had divided the Northumbrian Church.
Rather than establishing a working group to explore the diversity of perspectives, those attending heard the arguments and reached a conclusion.
“This is deeply troubling,” explained a synodal consultant. “There appears to have been genuine dialogue, followed almost immediately by a decision. We can find no evidence of a subsequent consultation on whether participants felt sufficiently listened to.”
Particular concern has been expressed over King Oswiu's decision to adopt the Roman calculation of Easter.
“One cannot simply hear opposing views and then decide which is correct,” the consultant continued. “That risks creating the impression that the purpose of discussion is to arrive at an answer.”
A preliminary investigation has also failed to identify a single facilitator, breakout group, feedback form or designated moment of reflective silence.
More disturbingly, the assembly appears to have concluded within the same year in which it began.
“Modern synodality is about walking together,” the consultant explained. “At Whitby, they seem to have walked somewhere and then stopped.”
The delegation acknowledged that the decision brought greater consistency to the celebration of Easter, but questioned whether such an outcome adequately reflected the complexity of the journey.
“Unity is important, naturally. But we must be careful not to confuse unity with everybody doing the same thing.”
The advisers have proposed a three-year programme to revisit the methodology of the original synod, beginning with a listening exercise to establish whether a decision was ever necessary.
A second phase will consider the experiences of those whose preferred calculation of Easter was not adopted.
The final phase will explore how the Church might move beyond the restrictive assumption that a synod must conclude.
St Hilda, whose monastery hosted the original gathering, has been praised for her commitment to bringing the Church together.
However, the delegation has expressed reservations about the apparent absence of a permanent synodal secretariat.
A report is expected to conclude that the Synod of Whitby was a valuable beginning, unfortunately undermined by its insistence on finishing.
The Northern Thurible is a satirical publication. The modern delegation, quotations and investigation are invented. The Synod of Whitby was a genuine historical gathering, and St Hilda's contribution to the Church is treated with the respect it deserves. No evidence has emerged that the seventh-century Church employed a Director of Synodal Accompaniment.

Leave a Reply