Officials insist flexibility is essential, provided it is exercised strictly in accordance with their instructions.
ROME — Five years after the publication of Traditionis custodes, the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments has reaffirmed its absolute, unconditional and non-negotiable opposition to rigidity within the Catholic Church.
In a retrospective assessment of the legislation, officials expressed disappointment that traditional Catholics continued to display an unhealthy attachment to practices which the Church itself had maintained for centuries.
“The problem is their unwillingness to change,” explained a senior official. “We have made our position perfectly clear, repeatedly, and have absolutely no intention of reconsidering it.”
The Dicastery pointed to its subsequent clarifications, restrictions and requirements for special permission as evidence of its tireless commitment to pastoral flexibility.
“Some people have suggested that our approach is inflexible,” the official continued. “This is completely unacceptable, and we will not tolerate any further discussion of it.”
Asked whether the Church's much-celebrated commitment to synodal listening might extend to Catholics attached to the older liturgy, the official appeared surprised.
“Of course we listen to them. We have listened to them for five years. Unfortunately, they persist in saying the same things.”
He added that genuine dialogue required participants to approach discussions without predetermined conclusions, particularly the conclusion that they should be allowed to continue attending the Mass they had always attended.
The Dicastery also rejected suggestions that restrictions on the older form of the Roman Rite were inconsistent with the Church's celebration of cultural and liturgical diversity.
“Diversity is one of the Church's greatest treasures,” the official explained. “But we must be very careful about allowing too much of it.”
The review concluded that significant progress had been made in overcoming rigidity, although further work remained necessary among those Catholics who continued to confuse fidelity to tradition with fidelity to tradition.
Officials confirmed that additional guidance might be issued should the faithful continue to misunderstand the importance of unquestioning openness.
The Northern Thurible is an independent Catholic satirical newspaper. This article is fictional satire inspired by Pope Francis's 2021 motu proprio Traditionis custodes and subsequent documents issued by the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments. The five-year review, official statements and quotations are invented for comic purposes. They do not represent actual statements or proceedings of the Dicastery or its officials.

Leave a Reply