THE NORTHERN THURIBLE | SATIRE
After 100 per cent of parish partnerships submit their findings, diocesan authorities face the unprecedented possibility of having to make a decision.
HEXHAM AND NEWCASTLE — The Diocese of Hexham and Newcastle has entered a potentially dangerous new phase of its Pastoral Strategy after it emerged that parishioners have begun completing the discernment process and, in several cases, expecting something to happen as a result.
In his pastoral letter for World Mission Sunday, Bishop Stephen Wright confirmed that more than 90 per cent of parishes had participated in both stages of reflection, with 100 per cent of parish partnerships submitting their responses.
The remarkable achievement has presented diocesan authorities with a difficulty for which no established pastoral procedure appears to exist: the faithful have listened, reflected, discerned and, in some cases, reached conclusions.
Attention will now turn to discerning whether those conclusions should be permitted to influence any decisions.
Benedict, the Diocese's Acting Director of Pastoral Discernment and Strategic Listening, confirmed that the situation had become increasingly serious.
“We have now listened to everybody,” he explained. “The difficulty is that some people have started expecting us to do something about what they've said.”
According to Benedict, a number of parish partnerships have reached the limit of what they can reasonably discern locally and have begun requesting decisions from the Bishop.
“This is an entirely unforeseen development,” he continued. “Our understanding was that parishioners would participate in a continuous process of prayerful listening. Nobody anticipated that they might eventually stop talking.”
The Diocese has consequently established a working group to determine whether the completion of discernment constitutes a decision, which would be contrary to the spirit of ongoing discernment.
“We must remember that the Holy Spirit moves in mysterious ways,” Benedict explained. “Fortunately, we have developed a comprehensive framework to ensure He follows the correct procedures.”
The situation deteriorated further when one parish pastoral council reportedly voted unanimously to repair a leaking church roof without first establishing a subcommittee to consider the pastoral implications of dry parishioners.
The decision was immediately referred to the Diocesan Discernment Oversight Group amid concerns that the council had acted on a practical problem rather than discerning its underlying synodal significance.
In a separate incident, a parishioner was asked to withdraw his suggestion that the principal priority of a Catholic parish might be the celebration of Mass and the administration of the sacraments.
“Nobody is disputing the importance of the sacraments,” Benedict clarified. “But we must be careful not to allow an excessive focus on Catholic worship to distract us from the wider mission of the Catholic Church.”
The pastoral strategy has nevertheless identified significant agreement around several priorities, including formation, lay participation, young people, communication and the future use of parish buildings.
Benedict welcomed the findings but warned against allowing this consensus to undermine the Diocese's commitment to further consultation.
“Consensus is a very encouraging outcome of discernment,” he said. “Naturally, we shall now need to consult on whether the consensus accurately represents the consensus.”
The Bishop's pastoral letter makes clear that final decisions rest with him, although he has emphasised the importance of appropriate consultation and careful consideration.
This has prompted speculation that the Diocese may eventually reach the highly unusual stage of somebody deciding something.
Benedict was keen to reassure parishioners that no such development was imminent.
“We are committed to moving forward together,” he explained. “But moving forward should not be confused with arriving anywhere.”
To assist with the next stage, the Diocese is preparing a comprehensive document entitled Discerning the Discernment: A Synodal Framework for Understanding What We Have Already Been Told.
It will be accompanied by a supplementary guide, Listening to Those Who Have Finished Listening, and a parish self-assessment tool designed to identify communities at risk of reaching premature conclusions.
The documents are expected to be circulated for consultation, following a preliminary consultation on the appropriate format for consultation documents.
Meanwhile, Benedict confirmed that the Diocese had written to the Holy See seeking clarification on whether the Holy Spirit could legitimately inspire a parish to reach a decision before the conclusion of the approved diocesan discernment timetable.
A response is awaited.
Until then, the faithful are encouraged to remain open to the promptings of the Spirit, provided these are submitted in writing, endorsed by the parish partnership and received before the diocesan deadline.
The Northern Thurible is an independent Catholic satirical newspaper. This article is a work of parody inspired by Bishop Stephen Wright's genuine pastoral letter for World Mission Sunday, 18 October 2026. The characters, dialogue and absurd developments are invented for satirical purposes.
Leave a Reply