Parish music committee welcomes opportunity to discover new approaches to worship, provided none of them involve Gregorian chant.
NORTH EAST ENGLAND — A parish guitarist has enrolled on a six-month course in contemporary worship after expressing concern that the Catholic Church has yet to develop a sufficiently comprehensive musical tradition.
The decision was welcomed by members of the parish music committee, who have spent several years exploring new and innovative ways of encouraging congregational participation.
Kevin, 43, who has played acoustic guitar at the 10.30am Sunday Mass since 2011, said he hoped the course would help him discover fresh approaches to worship.
"We've been singing the same songs for years," he explained. "I think it's time we explored something new."
His announcement prompted an unexpected intervention from the parish organist, Arthur, 78, who suggested that the Church might already possess a reasonably extensive collection of sacred music.
"There's rather a lot of it," Arthur observed.
Kevin acknowledged the point but questioned whether the material would be suitable for contemporary Catholic worship.
Arthur explained that much of it had been composed specifically for Catholic worship.
This caused some confusion.
"Yes, but is it relevant?" Kevin asked.
Arthur suggested that relevance might reasonably be established by the fact that the music had accompanied the Church's liturgy for several centuries.
The committee agreed to consider the matter at a later date.
Kevin subsequently outlined his ambitions for the course, explaining that he hoped to develop a more authentic understanding of worship through songwriting, musical expression and personal reflection.
Arthur produced a copy of the Liber Usualis.
"This might help," he said.
The book was passed around the committee, whose members expressed surprise at its considerable size.
Eileen, the parish's Coordinator for Contemporary Liturgical Engagement, asked whether it contained any suitable opening songs.
Arthur explained that it included chants for the Mass, the Divine Office and numerous celebrations throughout the liturgical year.
"Are they all in Latin?" she asked.
"Mostly."
The committee agreed that further investigation was required.
Particular concern was expressed about the absence of guitar chords above the musical notation.
Kevin examined several pages before concluding that the book would be difficult to incorporate into his present repertoire.
"There aren't any chord diagrams," he said. "How are we supposed to know when to change from G to D?"
Arthur explained the principles of Gregorian notation.
Kevin suggested that a modern edition might be more accessible.
The organist replied that the notation had already proved reasonably accessible to monks, priests and choirs for approximately a thousand years.
"Perhaps they had more time," Kevin observed.
The committee then considered whether Gregorian chant might meet the parish's commitment to active participation.
Eileen expressed reservations.
"Some of these chants are very old," she explained. "We mustn't assume that something is suitable for modern Catholics simply because the Church has been using it for centuries."
Arthur reminded her that Gregorian chant was given particular recognition in the Church's liturgical tradition.
"Yes," Eileen replied. "But the Church has moved on considerably since then."
Asked when this development had occurred, she said she believed it was sometime around 1974.
Meanwhile, Kevin has begun preparing for his course by reviewing his existing collection of worship songs.
He confirmed that his repertoire currently consists of fourteen pieces, although several can be performed at different speeds.
"We like to keep things varied," he explained.
Arthur suggested that the parish might begin by introducing a simple Gregorian setting of the Kyrie.
The suggestion was referred to the Music and Participation Subcommittee.
A preliminary assessment concluded that the Kyrie presented several difficulties, principally because it was in Greek rather than Latin.
"This is exactly the sort of confusion we're trying to avoid," Eileen explained.
Kevin proposed retaining the existing sung response, which he described as familiar, welcoming and contemporary.
Arthur pointed out that the piece had been written in 1978.
"Exactly," Kevin replied. "Modern."
The committee has also expressed interest in developing new material for Advent, Lent and Easter.
Arthur suggested that the Church possessed a substantial collection of seasonal hymns, antiphons and chants.
Eileen welcomed his enthusiasm but warned against relying too heavily upon inherited material.
"We're trying to create something that speaks to the present generation," she explained.
Arthur asked whether the present generation was not also entitled to inherit the musical tradition of the Church.
The question was added to the agenda for the next meeting.
Kevin remains enthusiastic about the course and hopes to return with a renewed appreciation of worship, together with several original compositions.
"I'd really like to write something that captures the mystery of the Eucharist," he said.
Arthur suggested Adoro te devote.
Kevin promised to look it up.
At the conclusion of the meeting, the committee thanked Arthur for his contribution and agreed that his knowledge of traditional sacred music was a valuable parish resource.
He was subsequently asked whether he would consider providing organ accompaniment for the contemporary worship group.
Arthur declined.
He explained that he had already spent sixty years learning to play music written for the Catholic Church and felt it would be a shame to abandon it now.
The committee recorded his response as evidence of resistance to musical renewal.
Kevin's course begins shortly.
Arthur will continue playing the organ at the Saturday evening Mass.
Attendance at that Mass has recently increased.
The music committee has commissioned a study to establish why.
The Northern Thurible is an independent Catholic satirical newspaper. The parish, characters, dialogue, course enrolment, committee proceedings and incidents described are satirical inventions. This article comments upon differing approaches to sacred music and does not describe the activities or views of any actual worship course, its organisers or participants.

Leave a Reply